Update on game idea

Instead of having an action packed FPS Pirate game i was thinking to do a adventure game based on exploring and solving puzzles. The game will be similar to Escape of Monkey Island but in First Person Perspective . I might go with this idea if you dont have to do the whole guns blasing FPS. Please comment any Ideas, thoughts or suggestions to my idea for it will help me out alot.

Cheers

Above are some pictures below of E.F.M.I(Escape from Monkey Island) to give you a better idea of what my game will be like.

One of my story ideas

One of my ideas for my first person shooter story is to have a pirate themed game because there isn't that many games based on the pirate theme and old pirate stories. A few games i know of is Escape from Monkey Island and Pirates of the Carribean. Orginally i wanted to do a sci-fi story but everything i think of has been done. Im just not sure on how well a pirate theme game would work as a FPS, it would work well as a TPS but not sure about an FPS. This is not my set story as i am still thinking of others.